Step-by-step fix
Step 1: Confirm the broil element is the likely problem
- Look at the upper heating element inside the oven cavity. If it is blistered, split, sagging, burned through, or has obvious hot spots, replacement is a good next step.
- Think about the symptom. A failed broil element often will not heat on broil, heats unevenly from the top, or may trip power if the element has shorted.
- If you have a multimeter and know how to use it safely, disconnect power first and check the removed element later for continuity. A failed element often tests open.
- Make sure the issue is not just a control setting mistake. Try a normal broil cycle once before taking the oven apart.
If it works: You have a clear reason to replace the broil element instead of guessing.
If it doesn’t: If the element looks normal and the oven still will not broil, the problem may be in the wiring, control, or thermostat side of the circuit rather than the element itself.
Stop if:- The breaker trips immediately when the oven is turned on and you see burned wiring, melted insulation, or arcing marks around the element connection area.
- The oven shows broader electrical problems such as no power, dead controls, or multiple heating functions failing at once.
Step 2: Shut off power and set up the oven
- Turn the range off at the breaker or unplug it if the plug is accessible.
- Open the oven door and let the oven cool fully if it was recently used.
- Remove the oven racks so you have room to work under the top of the oven cavity.
- Put on gloves and use a flashlight to locate the screws that hold the broil element to the back wall or ceiling area of the oven.
If it works: The oven is cool, de-energized, and clear enough to work safely.
If it doesn’t: If you cannot confirm power is off, do not touch the element terminals or mounting area.
Stop if:- You cannot safely disconnect power to the range.
- The mounting area is badly rusted, broken, or too damaged to hold the new element securely.
Step 3: Remove the old broil element carefully
- Take out the mounting screws while supporting the element with your free hand.
- Pull the element slightly toward you just enough to expose the wire terminals behind it.
- Hold the wire connectors so they do not slip back through the insulation or rear opening, then disconnect the wires from the element terminals.
- If a connector is tight, use needle-nose pliers on the metal terminal, not on the wire insulation.
- Set the old element aside and compare it to the new one for shape, terminal style, and overall size.
If it works: The old element is out and the oven wires are still accessible.
If it doesn’t: If the wires keep slipping backward, stop and secure them gently before they disappear into the insulation space.
Stop if:- A wire terminal is burned off, brittle, or too loose to make a safe connection.
- The new element does not match the old one closely enough to install with confidence.
Step 4: Install the new broil element
- Attach the oven wires to the new element terminals firmly. The connectors should fit snugly without wobbling.
- Tuck the wires back carefully so they do not get pinched or rub on sharp metal edges.
- Line up the new element with the mounting holes and reinstall the screws.
- Tighten the screws until the element is secure, but do not overtighten and strip the mounting holes.
- Make sure the element sits level and does not touch the oven liner where it should not.
If it works: The new broil element is mounted securely and connected cleanly.
If it doesn’t: If the connectors feel loose, the repair may not hold. The terminal ends may need attention before the oven is used.
Stop if:- The wire terminals will not stay tight on the new element.
- The element cannot be mounted squarely because the bracket or oven wall is damaged.
Step 5: Reassemble and restore power
- Reinstall the oven racks.
- Close the oven door and clear away tools from the cooking area.
- Turn the breaker back on or plug the range back in.
- Set the oven to broil and watch through the door for the first few minutes instead of leaving it unattended.
If it works: The range is back together and ready for a controlled test.
If it doesn’t: If the control will not start a broil cycle, recheck the settings and confirm the range has power.
Stop if:- You see sparks, smell strong burning insulation, or hear arcing after power is restored. Turn power back off immediately.
Step 6: Verify the repair in real use
- Let the broil cycle run long enough for the new element to begin heating evenly across its length.
- Expect a brief new-part smell the first time it heats, but it should fade quickly.
- Test actual cooking performance with a short broil task, such as browning the top of a dish, to confirm the oven now heats from above as expected.
- After the test, look once more inside the oven to make sure the element is still secure and sitting normally.
If it works: The broil function heats normally and the new element stays stable during use.
If it doesn’t: If the new element does not heat, heats only partly, or the breaker trips again, the problem is likely elsewhere in the broil circuit and needs deeper diagnosis.
Stop if:- The new element glows unevenly with obvious arcing at a terminal.
- The breaker trips again or the wiring area shows fresh burn marks after the test.
Replacement Parts
Repair Riot may earn a commission from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.
FAQ
How do I know the broil element is bad?
A bad broil element may look cracked, blistered, or burned through, and the oven may stop heating from the top. In some cases it can also short and trip power.
Can I replace a broil element myself?
Many homeowners can if the element is accessible from inside the oven and the wiring is still in good shape. The key is shutting off power first and stopping if you find burned terminals or damaged wires.
Why does the new element need to match so closely?
The shape, terminal style, and electrical rating need to match so it mounts correctly and heats the way the oven was designed to heat. A close visual and compatibility match helps avoid ordering the wrong part.
What if the new broil element still does not heat?
If the new element is installed correctly and still does not heat, the fault may be in the wiring, control, relay, or another part of the broil circuit rather than the element itself.
Is a slight smell normal after replacement?
Yes. A brief new-part smell on the first heat cycle can be normal. Shut the oven off if you smell strong burning insulation, see smoke that does not clear, or notice sparking.