Step-by-step fix
Step 1: Make sure the cover is the real problem
- Look at the in use cover closely for cracks, a warped lid, broken hinge parts, missing screws, or a gasket that no longer seals.
- Open and close the lid several times. If it will not latch, will not sit flat, or leaves obvious gaps around the cord opening, replacement makes sense.
- Check the receptacle itself. If the outlet is loose in the box, scorched, wet inside, or physically damaged, the problem is bigger than the cover.
- Make note of whether the cover mounts vertically or horizontally and whether it fits a standard duplex outlet or a larger GFCI or decorator-style face.
If it works: You have confirmed the cover is damaged or no longer sealing, and the outlet and box appear sound enough for a cover replacement.
If it doesn’t: If the cover still seals well, try cleaning the gasket and hinge area first instead of replacing it.
Stop if:- The receptacle is burned, cracked, loose in the box, or shows signs of water intrusion inside the electrical box.
- The wall or mounting surface is rotted, crumbling, or too damaged to hold the new cover securely.
Step 2: Shut off power and prep the area
- Unplug anything connected to the outdoor outlet.
- Turn off the breaker that feeds the receptacle.
- Use a non-contact voltage tester at the outlet face and around the box opening to confirm power is off.
- Wipe away dirt, spider webs, and standing moisture so you can see the mounting area clearly.
If it works: The outlet is unplugged, the breaker is off, and the work area is dry and ready.
If it doesn’t: If your tester still shows power, stop and identify the correct breaker before removing anything.
Stop if:- You cannot confirm the outlet is de-energized.
- The box area is actively wet from a leak, damaged conduit, or water entering the wall.
Step 3: Remove the old in use cover
- Support the old cover with one hand and remove the mounting screws with the other.
- Pull the cover straight off so you do not crack the box ears or drag old gasket material into the receptacle opening.
- Remove any old foam gasket, brittle sealant, or broken plastic pieces left behind on the box or cover plate area.
- Keep the screws if they are in good shape, but replace rusted or stripped hardware.
If it works: The old cover is off and the mounting surface is exposed and clean enough for the new part.
If it doesn’t: If the cover will not come free, check for hidden screws or sealant holding it in place and cut the sealant carefully instead of prying hard.
Stop if:- The electrical box shifts in the wall when you remove the cover.
- The mounting holes are broken or too stripped to hold the new cover securely.
Step 4: Match and assemble the new cover
- Compare the new cover to the old one before installing it. Confirm the orientation, device opening, hinge direction, and screw spacing all match.
- Install any included gasket or insert pieces the way the cover is designed to use them.
- If the instructions allow either vertical or horizontal mounting, set it up now so the lid opens in the most natural direction for your outlet location.
- Apply a small bead of exterior-rated sealant only where needed around the box edge if the old seal was clearly failing and the new cover design does not already provide a full gasket seal.
If it works: The new cover is configured to fit your outlet and ready to mount without forcing anything.
If it doesn’t: If the new cover does not line up cleanly with the box and outlet style, exchange it for the correct cover instead of modifying it.
Stop if:- The replacement cover does not match the outlet style or box layout.
- You would need to drill new holes in the electrical box or force the cover to make it fit.
Step 5: Install the new cover and check lid movement
- Set the new cover in place and start the screws by hand so they thread evenly.
- Tighten the screws until the cover is snug and the gasket is compressed evenly, but do not overtighten and crack the plastic.
- Open and close the lid several times to make sure it swings freely and latches properly.
- Plug in a cord if this cover is meant to protect an outlet while in use, then close the lid around the cord and check that the flap or opening still shields the receptacle.
If it works: The new cover is mounted securely, the lid moves smoothly, and it closes the way it should with or without a cord.
If it doesn’t: If the lid binds or will not close around the cord, loosen the cover slightly and re-center it before tightening again.
Stop if:- The cover cracks during installation.
- The lid cannot close enough to protect the outlet because the receptacle sits too far out, too far in, or is mounted crooked.
Step 6: Restore power and verify it holds up in real use
- Turn the breaker back on.
- Test the outlet with a plug-in device or the receptacle's normal test and reset controls if it is a GFCI-type outlet.
- Leave a cord plugged in for a few minutes if that is how the outlet is commonly used, then confirm the cover still stays closed and sheds water away from the opening.
- Check again after the next rain or sprinkler cycle to make sure no moisture is collecting inside the cover.
If it works: The outlet works normally and the new in use cover stays closed, aligned, and protective in everyday use.
If it doesn’t: If the outlet trips, gets damp inside, or the cover will not stay sealed, inspect the box, gasket, and receptacle condition for a deeper weatherproofing problem.
Stop if:- Water is still getting inside the cover or box after replacement.
- The outlet stops working, trips repeatedly, or shows signs of heat after power is restored.
Replacement Parts
Repair Riot may earn a commission from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.
FAQ
Do I need to replace the whole outlet to replace the in use cover?
Not usually. If the receptacle is in good shape and mounted securely, you can often replace just the cover. If the outlet is loose, cracked, burned, or wet inside the box, address that first.
How do I know which replacement cover to buy?
Match the box layout, vertical or horizontal orientation, and the device style behind the cover. A cover for a standard duplex outlet may not fit a GFCI or decorator-style receptacle.
Can I reuse the old screws?
Yes, if they are clean and not rusted or stripped. Replace damaged hardware so the new cover can clamp down evenly and stay weather resistant.
Should I put caulk around the new cover?
Only where needed. Many covers use a gasket to seal to the box. If the old sealant failed or the mounting surface is uneven, a light bead of exterior-rated sealant can help, but do not block drainage paths built into the cover design.
Why does the lid not close with a cord plugged in?
The cover may be the wrong style, mounted off-center, or paired with a bulky plug that the cover was not designed to accommodate. Re-center the cover first, then confirm you bought the correct in use style for that outlet.