Step-by-step fix
Step 1: Make sure the heating element is the right repair
- Look for symptoms that fit a failed element: not enough hot water, hot water that runs out quickly, or water that is only lukewarm.
- If your heater has upper and lower elements, remember that one failed element can still leave you with some hot water, just not normal recovery or full tank heating.
- Turn off power at the breaker, remove the access panel over the suspected element, and verify power is off with a non-contact voltage tester before touching anything.
- If you have a multimeter and know how to use it, disconnect the wires from the element and check the element for continuity or resistance. An open reading usually means the element has failed.
- Check the area for signs of a leaking tank, burned wiring, or heavy corrosion around the element opening.
If it works: The symptoms and basic checks point to a failed heating element, and the surrounding area looks safe enough for replacement.
If it doesn’t: If the element tests good or both elements seem intact, the problem may be a thermostat, reset issue, sediment buildup, or another water heater fault.
Stop if:- The tank itself is leaking from the body or seams.
- Wiring is badly burned, melted, or brittle beyond the element terminals.
- You cannot confirm power is off at the heater.
Step 2: Shut off power and drain the tank below the element
- Turn the water heater breaker fully off.
- Close the cold water supply valve to the heater.
- Open a nearby hot water faucet to relieve pressure in the tank.
- Connect a garden hose to the drain valve and run the hose to a safe drain area.
- Open the drain valve and let out enough water so the water level drops below the element you are replacing.
- Keep a bucket or towels nearby because some water usually remains behind the element.
If it works: Power is off, pressure is relieved, and the tank water level is below the element opening.
If it doesn’t: If water will not drain, the drain valve may be clogged with sediment. Try briefly opening and closing it or use the hot faucet to help vent the tank.
Stop if:- Water coming from the hose is dangerously hot and you cannot route it safely.
- The shutoff valve or drain valve is leaking heavily or will not operate safely.
Step 3: Remove the old heating element
- Take off the access cover and fold back the insulation.
- If present, carefully peel back any protective plastic shield without tearing it.
- Take a clear photo of the wire connections so you can reconnect them the same way.
- Loosen the terminal screws and move the wires aside.
- Fit the element wrench onto the element and turn counterclockwise to break it loose.
- Unscrew the element by hand once loose and pull it straight out.
- Remove the old gasket if it stayed behind in the opening.
If it works: The old element and gasket are out, and the tank opening is clear.
If it doesn’t: If the element is stuck, apply steady pressure with the element wrench rather than jerking it. A short extension bar can help, but avoid twisting the tank fittings.
Stop if:- The mounting area is cracked, badly deformed, or too corroded to seal properly.
- The element opening spins or the tank fitting appears loose in the tank.
Step 4: Install the new element and reconnect the wiring
- Compare the new element to the old one to make sure the length, shape, and terminals match.
- Place the new gasket on the new element as intended for that style.
- Insert the new element into the opening and thread it in by hand first to avoid cross-threading.
- Tighten the element firmly with the element wrench so the gasket can seal, but do not overtighten to the point of damaging the threads.
- Reconnect the wires to the same terminals you photographed earlier and tighten the terminal screws securely.
- Reposition any plastic shield and insulation, but leave the metal access cover off until you check for leaks.
If it works: The new element is installed squarely, the gasket is seated, and the wiring is back in place.
If it doesn’t: If the element will not thread in smoothly by hand, back it out and start again. Cross-threading can ruin the opening.
Stop if:- The new element does not match the old one closely enough to install correctly.
- The terminal screws will not tighten securely or the wire ends are damaged.
Step 5: Refill the tank completely before restoring power
- Close the drain valve and remove the hose.
- Open the cold water supply valve to refill the tank.
- Leave a nearby hot water faucet open while the tank fills so trapped air can escape.
- Wait until the hot faucet runs a full, steady stream of water without sputtering.
- Check around the new element for drips. Tighten the element slightly if needed to stop a minor seep.
- Once the area stays dry, reinstall the insulation and access cover.
If it works: The tank is full, air is purged, and the new element area is dry.
If it doesn’t: If you still hear air spitting from the hot faucet, keep the tank filling until the flow is steady. Do not restore power to a partially filled tank.
Stop if:- The element continues to leak after a careful slight retightening.
- The drain valve or another tank fitting starts leaking heavily during refill.
Step 6: Turn power back on and confirm the repair holds
- Turn the breaker back on only after the tank is completely full.
- Give the heater time to recover and make hot water.
- Run hot water at a faucet and check that water temperature and hot water volume improve compared with before the repair.
- Recheck the access panel area and the element opening for any sign of leaking after the heater has heated up.
- Use the heater normally over the next day and confirm it keeps up without tripping the breaker or losing hot water too quickly.
If it works: Hot water returns normally, the breaker stays on, and the new element remains dry in real use.
If it doesn’t: If hot water is still weak, another element, a thermostat, a reset issue, or heavy sediment may still be part of the problem.
Stop if:- The breaker trips after power is restored.
- You smell burning, hear arcing, or see water leaking onto electrical parts.
- The heater still does not produce hot water after a normal recovery period.
Replacement Parts
Repair Riot may earn a commission from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.
FAQ
Do I need to drain the whole water heater to replace an element?
Usually no. You only need to drain the tank until the water level is below the element you are removing.
What happens if power is turned on before the tank is full?
A dry-fired element can burn out very quickly. Always refill the tank completely and purge air from a hot faucet before restoring power.
Should I replace both elements at the same time?
If the heater uses two elements and one has failed, many homeowners replace only the bad one. If the other element is old and performance has been declining, replacing both can make sense while the tank is already shut down.
Why is my new element leaking?
The most common causes are a misaligned gasket, debris on the sealing surface, cross-threading, or not tightening the element enough to compress the gasket.
How do I know whether the upper or lower element is bad?
A failed upper element often causes very limited or no hot water. A failed lower element often gives you some hot water, but not enough, and recovery can feel slow.