Direct answer: If auxiliary heat stays on, the most common causes are thermostat settings, restricted airflow, or the outdoor heat pump not carrying the load. Start by checking whether the thermostat is in emergency heat, whether the filter is packed, and whether the outdoor unit is actually running.
Most likely: Most of the time this is either a thermostat calling for backup heat when it should not, or the heat pump side is underperforming because of airflow trouble, outdoor unit trouble, or very cold weather.
First separate normal behavior from a real fault. In very cold weather, auxiliary heat may run a lot. If it stays on in mild weather, never drops out, or the thermostat shows AUX or EM heat for hours while the outdoor unit is idle, treat that as a problem. Reality check: backup heat costs more to run, so this is worth chasing down. Common wrong move: cranking the thermostat up several degrees at once, which can call auxiliary heat even on a healthy system.
Don’t start with: Do not start by replacing relays, boards, or other hidden electrical parts. On a heat pump, that gets expensive fast and it is easy to guess wrong.
The house heats, but the thermostat keeps showing AUX even after the set temperature is reached or during normal mild-weather heating.
Start here: Check thermostat mode, recent schedule changes, and whether the setpoint was raised several degrees at once.
The thermostat says EM Heat or Emergency Heat, and the outdoor unit may stay off while indoor heat still runs.
Start here: Turn emergency heat off and return the thermostat to normal heat mode before doing anything else.
Indoor air is warm, but the outdoor section is silent, the fan is not spinning, or the unit is heavily iced while AUX stays on.
Start here: Check the outdoor breaker or disconnect and look for solid ice buildup or obvious damage. Do not open electrical panels.
Each time you raise the temperature a few degrees, AUX appears quickly and stays on longer than expected.
Start here: Lower the setpoint closer to room temperature and let the system recover gradually. Then check filter and airflow.
This is common after a power outage, battery change, schedule edit, or a big manual temperature increase. The system may be doing exactly what it was told to do.
Quick check: Confirm the thermostat is in normal heat mode, not EM Heat, and set the temperature only 1 to 2 degrees above room temperature.
A packed filter, blocked returns, or closed supply registers can make the system deliver less heat, so auxiliary heat stays on to catch up.
Quick check: Inspect the air filter, make sure return grilles are clear, and open closed supply registers.
If the outdoor fan is not running, the unit is shut off, or the coil is buried in ice, the system leans on auxiliary heat because the heat pump side is not doing its job.
Quick check: With the thermostat calling for heat, listen for outdoor operation and look for heavy ice that does not clear on its own.
If settings and airflow are fine and the outdoor unit runs normally, a thermostat fault, wiring issue, or internal control problem can keep backup heat on longer than it should.
Quick check: Watch whether AUX stays on even in mild weather after the house reaches temperature and the system has had time to settle.
Emergency heat is the cleanest lookalike. If that mode is on, auxiliary heat staying on is expected.
Next move: If EM Heat was on and the system returns to normal heat operation, you found the problem. If AUX still stays on in normal heat mode, move to airflow and outdoor-unit checks.
What to conclude: You have ruled out the most common user-setting cause.
A heat pump that cannot move enough air often falls behind and calls backup heat longer than it should.
Next move: If AUX use drops after restoring airflow, the heat pump was likely struggling to keep up because of restriction. If airflow is decent and AUX still stays on, check whether the outdoor unit is actually heating.
What to conclude: You have either corrected a common load problem or ruled out the simplest indoor cause.
If the outdoor section is off, starved for power, or locked in ice, the system will lean hard on auxiliary heat.
Next move: If restoring power or clearing obvious blockage gets the outdoor unit running normally, auxiliary heat may drop back to occasional use. If the outdoor unit stays off, trips power, or remains heavily iced, this is no longer a simple homeowner fix.
A thermostat can keep calling auxiliary heat because of setup, staging behavior, or a fault, especially if the house is already warm enough.
Next move: If smaller setpoint changes stop the constant AUX calls, the issue was thermostat behavior rather than a failed heat pump component. If AUX stays on even with mild setpoint changes and normal outdoor operation, the thermostat or system controls need closer diagnosis.
By now you have separated normal operation from the two most realistic repair paths a homeowner can act on: thermostat trouble or a larger heat pump problem.
A good result: If the thermostat branch fits, replacing it with the correct heat pump thermostat often solves constant AUX calls caused by bad staging or bad sensing.
If not: If the thermostat branch does not fit, stop at observation and let a pro test the outdoor unit and controls safely.
What to conclude: You have a clear next move instead of guessing at expensive hidden parts.
Repair Riot may earn a commission from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.
Yes, during very cold weather, defrost cycles, or after a big thermostat setback, auxiliary heat can run for a while. It is less normal if it stays on in mild weather or never seems to drop out after the house reaches temperature.
AUX heat is backup heat that the system brings on automatically when the heat pump needs help. Emergency heat is a manual mode that shuts the heat pump side out and runs backup heat by itself.
Absolutely. A restricted filter cuts airflow, which reduces heat delivery and can make the system call backup heat longer to keep up.
Only after the basics check out. If emergency heat is off, airflow is good, and the outdoor unit runs normally, then a bad or misconfigured heat pump thermostat becomes a much stronger suspect.
That is often normal if you raise the setpoint several degrees at once. Many heat pump thermostats call auxiliary heat to recover faster. Smaller adjustments usually reduce that behavior.
Then look at the weather, airflow, and thermostat behavior first. If those do not explain it, the system may have a defrost, sensor, electrical, or refrigerant-side problem that needs HVAC testing.