No heat at all on broil
The display accepts the broil setting, but the oven cavity stays cool and food never starts to brown on top.
Start here: Start with the control setting, door position, and a visual check for any upper heat source activity.
Oven Broil Troubleshooting
Cafe Oven Broiler Not Working
Direct answer: When a Cafe oven broiler stops working, the usual causes are the wrong mode or door position, a failed oven broil heating element on electric models, or a weak oven igniter on gas models. Start with the simple setup checks, then look for whether the broiler glows, sparks, or heats at all.
Most likely: Most often, this comes down to a broil setting issue or a failed oven broil heating element or oven igniter, not the oven control itself.
Broil problems can look the same from the front panel but act very differently once you watch the oven for a minute. A dead electric broil element, a gas igniter that glows but never lights, and a simple wrong-mode issue all leave different clues. Reality check: if bake still works, the oven is not fully dead. Common wrong move: replacing parts before confirming whether you have an electric-style element problem or a gas-style ignition problem.
Don’t start with: Do not start by ordering an oven control board. Controls are expensive, fitment-sensitive, and usually not the first thing to fail on a broil-only complaint.
If the oven says it is broiling but the top never gets hot,watch for a glowing upper element on electric models or ignition activity on gas models before buying anything.
If the broiler works weakly or unevenly,check the rack position, door behavior, and whether the upper heat source is only heating part of the way.
Last reviewed: 2026-04-17
What the broiler is doing
Electric broil element stays dark
On an electric oven, the upper broil element never glows red or only one small section changes color.
Start here: Look closely at the oven broil heating element for blistering, cracks, or a burned-through spot.
Gas broiler does not light
You may hear a click or see an igniter glow, but the flame never spreads across the broiler burner.
Start here: Watch whether the oven igniter glows strongly and whether gas ignition happens within a short time.
Broiler heats weakly or unevenly
The top heat comes on, but browning is slow, patchy, or only one side of the pan cooks well.
Start here: Check rack position, foil misuse, door position, and whether the heat source is working across its full length.
Most likely causes
1. Wrong broil mode, temperature choice, or door position
Many broil complaints are setup issues. Some ovens have high and low broil, and some broil differently with the door fully closed versus slightly open.
Quick check: Cancel the cycle, let the oven reset for a minute, then start broil again and confirm the mode on the display and the door position the oven expects.
2. Failed oven broil heating element
On electric ovens, a broil element can burn open and still look mostly normal until you inspect it closely. Sometimes only part of it heats.
Quick check: Look for a bright, even glow across the upper element. If it stays dark or has a split, bubble, or burned spot, that is a strong clue.
3. Weak or failed oven igniter on a gas broiler
A gas broiler may have an igniter that glows but is too weak to open the gas valve reliably. That gives you a no-broil complaint even though something appears to be happening.
Quick check: Start broil and watch through the opening. If the igniter glows but the burner never lights, the oven igniter is a leading suspect.
4. Oven temperature sensor or control problem
This is less common, but it moves up the list if the broil source tests good and the oven still never sends heat when broil is selected.
Quick check: If bake and broil both act strangely, preheat times are erratic, or the display throws heating-related errors, stop guessing and move toward sensor or control diagnosis.
Step-by-step fix
Step 1: Confirm the broil setting and basic operation first
You want to rule out the easy stuff before opening anything up. A surprising number of broil calls are mode, timer, or door-position issues.
- Cancel the current cycle and let the oven sit idle for about 1 minute.
- Set the oven to broil again and choose the normal broil option the oven offers.
- Make sure no delayed start, Sabbath-style hold, or timer lockout is active if your panel has those features.
- Check whether the oven door should be fully closed or slightly open during broiling for your setup, then try it the proper way.
- Move the rack to a normal broil position near the top, but not so close that cookware touches the upper heat source.
Next move: If the broiler starts heating normally now, the problem was likely a setting or operating issue rather than a failed part. If the display accepts broil but you still get no top heat, move on and identify whether you have an electric element problem or a gas ignition problem.
What to conclude: A clean restart with the right mode helps separate a simple control-use issue from an actual heating failure.
Stop if:
- The oven trips the breaker.
- You smell gas.
- You see sparking, arcing, or melted insulation.
- The control panel is dead or glitching badly.
Step 2: Watch what the upper heat source actually does
The fastest way to narrow this down is to watch for physical clues. Electric and gas broilers fail differently.
- Turn the oven light on and start broil.
- On an electric oven, look for the upper oven broil heating element to glow evenly after it has had a little time to heat.
- On a gas oven, look for the oven igniter to glow and listen for ignition, then watch for a steady flame at the broiler burner.
- If only part of an electric element glows, note exactly where it stops heating.
- If a gas igniter glows but no flame appears, note how long it glows before the cycle ends or stalls.
Next move: If you see normal upper heat or a steady broiler flame, the broiler itself may be working and the complaint may be weak performance from rack position, cookware, or expectations. If an electric element stays dark or a gas igniter glows without lighting the burner, you have a much clearer repair path.
What to conclude: A dark electric element points toward a failed oven broil heating element or a supply issue to that circuit. A glowing gas igniter with no flame strongly points toward a weak oven igniter.
Step 3: Inspect the broil hardware for visible damage
A close visual check often confirms the failure without any meter work. Start with what you can see safely.
- Turn power off to the oven at the breaker before touching anything inside.
- Let the oven cool fully.
- For an electric oven, inspect the upper oven broil heating element for blisters, cracks, burn-through spots, or a section that has sagged or separated.
- Check the element mounting area for heat damage or loose-looking connections where the element enters the rear wall.
- For a gas oven, inspect the oven igniter area for obvious cracking or damage and look for heavy grease buildup around the broiler burner that could affect ignition.
- Check the oven door gasket near the top corners. A badly torn gasket can let heat wash out and make broiling seem weak even when the heat source works.
Next move: If you find a clearly damaged oven broil heating element or a visibly failed igniter, that is enough to support replacing that part. If nothing looks damaged, the next check is whether the problem is limited to broil or affects oven heating more broadly.
Step 4: Compare broil behavior to bake behavior
This separates a broil-only failure from a wider oven problem. That matters before you spend money on parts.
- Restore power and test bake briefly after the oven is reassembled enough to run safely.
- See whether bake heats normally, heats slowly, or also fails.
- If bake works well but broil does not, keep your focus on the oven broil heating element, oven igniter, or broil-specific wiring.
- If both bake and broil are off, think beyond the broiler itself and consider the oven temperature sensor or control issue.
- If the panel shows an error or temperatures are erratic in both modes, write down the exact behavior before calling for service or testing further.
Next move: If bake is normal and broil is not, you have a targeted broil-side problem and can avoid chasing the whole oven. If both modes are failing or acting strangely, this is no longer a simple broiler-only repair for most homeowners.
Step 5: Replace the confirmed broil-side part or call for deeper electrical diagnosis
By now you should know whether this is a straightforward broil element or igniter repair, or whether the problem has moved into sensor, wiring, or control territory.
- Replace the oven broil heating element if the electric upper element is visibly damaged, stays dark, or only heats partway while bake still works normally.
- Replace the oven igniter if the gas broiler igniter glows but the broiler burner does not light reliably.
- Consider the oven temperature sensor only if both bake and broil temperatures are off or heating behavior is erratic without a clear broil element or igniter failure.
- Do not buy an oven control unless testing has ruled out the broil element, igniter, sensor, and wiring first.
- If the diagnosis points to wiring, relay, or control issues, book appliance service and give them the exact symptoms you observed in the earlier steps.
A good result: If the confirmed part is replaced and broil returns with strong, even top heat, run a short cooking test and recheck the door seal and rack position.
If not: If the new broil-side part does not restore operation, stop there and move to professional diagnosis for wiring or control faults.
What to conclude: A successful part replacement confirms the broil-side failure. No change after a supported replacement usually means the fault is upstream in wiring, sensor logic, or the control.
Replacement Parts
Repair Riot may earn a commission from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.
FAQ
Why does my oven bake but the broiler does not work?
That usually means the problem is limited to the broil side. On an electric oven, the oven broil heating element is a common failure. On a gas oven, a weak oven igniter is a common cause. It is less often the control when bake still works normally.
Can an oven broil element fail without looking badly damaged?
Yes. Some oven broil heating elements split or burn open in a way that is hard to see at first glance. If it stays dark on broil or only one section heats, the element can still be bad even without dramatic damage.
My gas broiler igniter glows orange. Does that mean it is good?
No. A glowing oven igniter can still be too weak to open the gas valve properly. If it glows but the broiler burner never lights, the igniter is still a leading suspect.
Should I replace the oven control board for a broiler problem?
Not first. A control issue is possible, but it is usually farther down the list than a failed oven broil heating element, weak oven igniter, or a broader sensor problem. Confirm the simpler failures before spending money on a control.
Can a bad oven door gasket make the broiler seem weak?
Yes, but it usually does not cause a total no-broil condition by itself. A torn or flattened oven door gasket can let heat escape and make top browning slow or uneven, especially near the front of the oven.
Is it safe to keep using bake if broil is not working?
Usually yes if bake works normally and there are no signs of burning, sparking, gas smell, or wiring damage. If the oven trips the breaker, smells hot, or shows any unsafe behavior, stop using it until it is repaired.